Feedback: Taking the Risk

 

Academic Panel Discussion

On the heels of both #BLC14 and #VLConf2014, where we (those present and those of us who watched from afar) repeatedly heard messages around the importance of understanding what works in education, getting feedback from students to teachers on their teaching, having the courage to fail forward, and finding ways to make our thinking visible, I reflected on my past year and those times when I took the risk to really hear the students. 

Here is one of those times.

The students in the above picture graduated high school between 2005 and 2011. They responded to a general invitation to speak to current students in their former school about the transition from high school to post-secondary.

We called this event an Academic Panel Discussion: The High School University Connection.

We had never done this before, but we needed something to inspire our students to engage in their learning. 

We couldn’t be sure of the outcome. Yes, we provided the panelists the questions, but there was really no way to guarantee that the resulting conversation would be useful/positive/meaningful.  We asked:

1. Looking back to the beginning of your university career, what aspect of the transition from high school to university challenged you?

2. In what ways did the work you did in high school merge, connect, or continue in university?

3. What skills did you learn in high school that you rely/relied on in university?

4. What skills did you learn in high school, but that you later wished you had practised more while in high school?

5. What skills did you learn in high school that you did not use in university?

6. What would you now tell your 16 year-old self to focus on? 

The conversation went on for 45 mins. The feedback was authentic, meaningful, and personal. And everyone listening in that room that day was changed. (More on this in another post to come.)

Would you be willing to take the risk? What opportunity for feedback are you willing to create?

 

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Teaching

2 responses to “Feedback: Taking the Risk

  1. Donna Fry

    It is so true that as much as we know the importance of feedback, it isn’t until we really take the risk of inviting authentic feedback that we can really benefit from it.

    Sometimes we are so busy moving forward that we forget to stop and ask if we are really rushing ahead in the right direction.

    I can’t wait to hear the rest of the story!

  2. Ms. Balen

    Why don’t we survey our graduates to find out if we are hitting the mark? This event was a risky. The former students were instructed to answer the questions honestly. That their candour would be important for the students and valuable for the staff. I will be advocating for us to repeat this event in the fall; to open it up to more students and more grads.

    Always glad to have you stop by Donna.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s